The Promise Lodge Series in Order

About the Promise Lodge series

Series Premise

The core premise centers on a group of Amish families who leave their established community in Coldstream, Missouri, after facing conflict and restrictions. Led by the visionary Preacher Amos Troyer and supported by strong-willed women like Mattie Schwartz and her sisters, the group purchases an abandoned farm and establishes a new settlement called Promise Lodge. The series follows their efforts to build homes, farms, and a close-knit community from the ground up while navigating personal challenges, family secrets, and the complexities of Amish faith and tradition. Each book typically focuses on a different couple finding love and purpose within this new settlement, while the larger story of Promise Lodge’s growth and the characters’ healing from past wounds runs throughout the saga.

Main Characters

The central characters are the founding members of Promise Lodge. Mattie Schwartz is a strong, compassionate widow who becomes a driving force in the new community, offering wisdom and encouragement to others. Her sisters, Christine and Rosetta, each bring their own strengths and personalities to the settlement. Preacher Amos Troyer is a kind, forward-thinking leader who envisions a more compassionate and flexible Amish community. Roman Schwartz, Mattie’s son, and other younger members of the founding families add layers of romance and personal growth to the stories. Recurring supporting characters include neighbors, friends, and occasional visitors who help or challenge the settlement’s progress. As the series progresses, new residents and romantic interests arrive, expanding the community and introducing fresh dynamics.

Setting

The setting is the newly established Promise Lodge community in Missouri. The abandoned farm the settlers purchase provides a blank canvas for their dreams — fields to be plowed, orchards to be tended, and simple homes to be built. The landscape is described with warmth and detail: rolling hills, fertile soil, a sparkling lake, and the gradual transformation of the property into a thriving Amish settlement. The setting reflects the themes of renewal and hard work, as the characters literally build their future one barn-raising and garden plot at a time. The close proximity of the families fosters both support and occasional conflict, creating an intimate, lived-in atmosphere.

Tone & Themes

The tone is warm, gentle, and hopeful, with a strong sense of community and quiet faith. Hubbard’s writing is comforting and sincere, emphasizing kindness, forgiveness, and the healing power of love. The mood is uplifting and reassuring, even when addressing difficult topics such as grief, betrayal, or family conflict. Themes include second chances and new beginnings; the importance of forgiveness and reconciliation; the strength of community and mutual support; the balance between tradition and necessary change; the power of love to heal past wounds; and the idea that God’s plan often unfolds in unexpected ways. The series gently celebrates the Amish values of simplicity, humility, and service while acknowledging the very human struggles that come with building a new life.

In the end, the Promise Lodge series offers a tender and uplifting look at faith, community, and the courage it takes to start over. Charlotte Hubbard has created a world where second chances are not only possible but celebrated, and where the simple act of building a home together can heal even the deepest wounds. The books provide comfort and hope without shying away from real emotional struggles, reminding readers that love, forgiveness, and hard work can transform broken places into places of belonging. For those who enjoy gentle Amish romances with strong community ties and heartfelt emotion, the series is a satisfying and nourishing read. It lingers like the scent of fresh-baked bread or the warmth of a shared meal after a long day of labor — simple, sustaining, and filled with the quiet beauty of lives rebuilt with faith and love. The saga ultimately affirms that no matter how scattered or damaged we may feel, there is always a place where we can plant new roots and find the promise of a brighter tomorrow.